Martin Luther
May 16, 2008
We catholics have a wealth of spiritual heroes within our own tradition, however, there exists great heroes beyond our structures as well, take Martin Luther for example. In more recent times we have begun to ditch the sterotypical images of Luther as a betrayer, destroyer of the Church etc., and have begun to see a man of great conviction and honour. What follows is a reflection from a Catholic Theologian regarding Martin Luther’s contribution to life and faith.
Catholic Theologian Todd summarized Luther in 1982 by saying:
“Of Luther himself it is impossible to speak summarily. The complex and remarkable story of his life, the tally of his works, and the witness of a great number of friends, acquaintances and enemies are there. Many loved him, many revered him, some were frightened of him, a few resentful. No one accused him, with any semblance of justification, of double dealing, or of cowardice. My principal image is of a man driven, driven by a passion for the Divine, driven, too, by a horror of evil; convinced of its eventual futility, he was ever conscious of its threat, and his life was one of prayer. His friends remembered him standing by the window of his room praying, often aloud. Under the rumbustious lover of life lay sensitivity, intelligence and imagination, and a failure to come to terms with a world which was never good enough, a failure he found confirmed in the crucifix, but glorified in what followed. At the Wartburg he wrote: ‘They threaten us with death. They would do better to threaten us with life.’

August 4, 2008 at 4:06 am
“take Martin Luther for example. In more recent times we have begun to ditch the sterotypical images of Luther as a betrayer, destroyer of the Church etc., and have begun to see a man of great conviction and honour. ”
Wait…what!? You are Catholic, right? ML was not a great man and sowed nothing but heresy and division within the Body of Christ.
August 4, 2008 at 3:06 pm
Just a response to the total dismissal of Martin Luther and here I draw upon the insight of the long-standing preacher to the Papal household Raniero Cantamalessa who is himself both a theologian and a biblical scholar. In Cantamalessa’s book on the Letter to the Romans, the author has recourse to the works of Luther and derives much insight (the footnotes reveal the specific references). In particular Cantamalessa draws upon Luther’s treatment of the central role of Christ in Redemption and the place of the Holy Spirit in Christian life. For both these contributions, he has no hesitation in placing Luther in the tradition of Augustinian theology( so beloved by Benedict xvi) and that of Orthodoxy (see chapter 8). I leave it to the Lord to have the final word on Luther.
August 7, 2008 at 1:15 pm
Thanks Tom for a bit of calm sanity! Walter, I don’t pretend to be a religious historian or theological expert, but I hope I know enough to take issue with your view here. Things, especially people, are rarely black and white in this world of ours, and someone with as much conviction as ML deserves at least some respect for his faith. I do personally believe that the one God who created us all in all our shapes, colours, beliefs and follies, should be the only black and white judge of anyone – the rest of us should settle for admitting to the shades of grey that surround most things and calmly respect other views/doctrines – and where possible seek to promote respect and communication, rarther than summary dismissal or statements like “we’re Cathloic right, so he/she must be wrong”! Be more at peace. Y&Y